Scott Freeman

    The Best Thoughts in Life are Free

    Browsing Posts published in 2006

    …when vacations and holidays were relaxing times. No more.

    Hours of putting together toys and suffering grievous bodily harm opening that packaging has led to one tired individual.

    At least I won my church fantasy football league. Congrats to Greg Kendall-Ball for winning my blog league.

    For those of you who are such a positive presence on my blog I wish you a wonderful holiday season. My God bless you during this time with family and friends. It is heart-warming to know that I have this community that, even when we disagree, can be so encouraging and edifying. I truly appreciate those of you who embody that Spirit of Christ in my life.

    In Micah 5:1, the impending siege by the Babylonians upon Jerusalem is prophesied. The destruction of Jerusalem at the hands of Nebuchadnezzar would be swift, merciless and complete.

    Yet, in verse 2 there is a message of hope—of deliverance and redemption.

    A ruler would come. It would not be to a world of opulence. It would not be to Jerusalem. It would not be amidst great fanfare and hoopla. Instead the ruler would be from Bethlehem.

    David was born in Bethlehem, about 5 miles outside of Jerusalem. The chief priests, teachers, and rabbis all concurred that this passage was an explicit prophesy of the coming Messiah.

    Jesus was the fulfillment of that prophesy in Micah 1 that says the Messiah would come from Bethlehem.

    But why Bethlehem? What message can we learn from this birth?

    What is significant about the way Jesus came to this earth?

    It’s not just about the fact that He came—it’s what He brought with Him:

    1. He brought justice into an unjust world—the proud people of Israel are now a subdued subject to the Roman power. As Genesis 49 tells us, the scepter of power has been removed from Judah and they are nothing more than vassals to the Great Roman Empire.

    Look at the lack of Justice:

    · The creator of the world born as the created.

    · The author of Heaven and earth born homeless

    · The Savior of all mankind outcast from His people

    · The paragon of Holiness born to an unwed teenager

    But Jesus would turn our ideas of justice on its head. He would teach us anew the virtue of justice in an unjust world

    2. He brought kindness into a cruel world—Could Jesus have been born under more cruel circumstances? Much has been made that there was no room in the inn. But where is Joseph’s family? He was from the Royal line of David. They had to travel back to their hometown to register. Surely, there was family there. Why do they have to stay in an inn? Is there no one who will acknowledge and embrace their kin and his pregnant fiancé? Is the shame too much for them to embrace Mary? Does Joseph have not a single friend who will take them in, from his own hometown? Will no one make space for a woman in her final moments of pregnancy? No compassion, no kindness.

    Instead, the Messiah is born in a feeding trough in a foul-smelling stable.

    You might think that maybe Joseph didn’t have any family. That there was no one who could extend that kindness. Yet, just 12 years later when Joseph takes his family to the temple for Passover there is an entire caravan of relatives and acquaintances. Where did they come from? Was 12 years ample time to restore them to the family’s good graces? To me the story is not the lack of room at the inn, but the lack of room among Joseph’s own people.

    3. He brought humility into an arrogant world—Jesus was born in a small town. Bethlehem was so small it is not even mentioned in the list of towns in Joshua or Nehemiah.

    The birth of the Savior of the world in such a little-known backwater is significant. There was no splash or birth announcement. No showers or cigars.

    Outside of the notice of some shepherds and angels, the birth was not recognized.

    His humble birth was set against the backdrop of an arrogant census. All of the world was to be registered, illustrating the Terraram Orbis Imperium (the empire of the whole earth). The purpose of this census was to be named and enrolled as part of the Roman Empire. Taxation was secondary, a sign of their subjection to the world power, namely Augustus.

    We see the idea that Augustus is cementing his legacy, stroking his pride and proclaiming to the world the far-reaching grasp of his power. It was unbridled arrogance to force these vassals to travel to their place of birth for the purpose of enrolling as subjects to the kingdom of Rome. The expense of this trip would have been a burden on such a young family but members of the royal family of David were compelled to return to their homeland.

    In that arrogant atmosphere, the humble king was born. Outside of any earthly herald, the cosmic savior of the universe stepped into flesh. A stark contrast to the arrogance of the Roman Empire.

    Interesting side-note #1—By the occasion of this census, the prophecy was fulfilled. Jesus would not have been born in Bethlehem, otherwise. God uses even our fallenness to achieve His aims.

    Interesting side-note #2—This registration would served to corroborate the claims of Jesus as being from the line of David. Years later Justin Martyr and Tertullian would refer to these roles as corroboration of Jesus’ lineage.

    The ignominy of Jesus’ birth is far too often lost on us. In fact, it was lost on the original readers of the Micah text as well.

    They knew the Messiah would be born in Bethlehem, yet they had such a limited perspective of what they would be.

    They see in Micah 5:3 that he will be born to a woman.

    But there is also the idea in the remainder of this passage that He will be king, that He will “stand and shepherd his people” (v. 4a), that He will “be their peace” (v. 5), and He will “deliver” them (v. 6)

    Here is one reason why the Jews failed to recognize Jesus as the Messiah: although many OT passages talked about Messiah as a “Suffering Servant” many more talked about Messiah as being a “Victorious Ruler.”

    They failed to see the incarnation as suffering servant and the resurrection as victorious ruler aspects of the one and same Messiah.

    For Jesus turned everything upside down. Conventional wisdom was turned on its head. The humiliation of His birth pointed to something greater. The low station of Bethlehem compels us to go deeper to find how Jesus lived and to seek to apply how He lived to our own lives.

    What we must learn from the birth (and life) of Jesus:

    1. Do Justice—Jesus brought justice into an unjust world. We must be people who are committed to the balanced pursuit of justice. When I say balanced, I mean that we often approach the concept of justice from the punitive aspect.

    But Justice also carries a tremendous restorative component. In our western mindset we often approach justice as offenders getting their due.

    But justice is about fairness. It is about making sure that the oppressed, the disadvantaged, the forgotten have a voice, have a champion.

    Justice is about doing right to others. The oppressed long for justice because it gives them relief.

    The poor longs for justice because it gives them assistance.

    The lost long for justice because it gives them hope.

    Those who dread justice are those who have been unjust—the ones who have failed to be fair.

    To live that Christ-centered life we must understand that there are social implications to justice in addition to the legal, punitive aspect.

    Look at how Jesus lived His life, who He broke bread with, who He ministered to: People in desperate need of justice: an adulterous woman, a shamed woman at a well, a leper, a tax collector—Justice for them was not punitive but restorative.

    Too often we look at proclaiming justice as pronouncing impending punishment—where to proclaim justice is to offer hope to the hopeless, homes to the homeless, salvation to a lost and dying world.

    2. Love Kindness—We live in an inconsiderate and rude time. We want what we want, when we want it—and anyone who keeps us from that is an inconvenience and a nuisance.

    Social interaction and good graces are sacrificed. We must be intentional about kindness—a hand up, a tender word, and a compassionate glance.

    In his book The Divine Conspiracy, Dallas Willard rails against our reliance on slogans that, to Christians, should make no sense. One of those slogans is “Practice random acts of kindness and senseless acts of beauty.” Instead he says we should be people who would “Practice routinely purposeful acts of kindness and intelligent acts of beaty,” We must be intentional.

    3. Walk Humbly with your God—Lord, it’s hard to be humble.

    But as Jesus demonstrated the ultimate humility in His birth, so we too must practice humility in our daily walk.

    The key to our humility is to place ourselves in Bethlehem, at the foot of a manger—to gaze upon the Celestial Maker of all creation as he encounters this world for the first time, not as God but as baby.

    The humility of lowering Himself to minister—to be just and kind in an unjust and cruel world should drive each of us to our knees—it is what God requires of us.

    Micah 6:8

    That is what Jesus did—He did justice, loved kindness and walked humbly with His God.

    How can we do anything different?

    Praise God for Bethlehem. It shows us His justice, His kindness, and His humility.

    And calls us to live the same way.

    There is one thing that drives me crazier than the crass commercialization of Christmas: the “Christmas Wars” that see well-intentioned Christians seeking to make Christmas and its observances mandatory for all.

    But there is nothing in the original Christmas story that anywhere indicates that Jesus wanted people to feel compelled to worship Him or to celebrate His birth. The manger is proof of that. The lowly birth was indicative of God’s approach to sharing the Good News.

    People don’t want to say “Merry Christmas?” Fine. They shouldn’t have to. Instead in our kindness and humility we should be the incarnation of Christ in this world.

    People should never be compelled to honor or follow any tenet in Christianity. They should not listen to us because we have power. They should listen to us because we are good.

    Isn’t that how He did it?

    It’s already been pointed out that there is an overwhelming number of female artists on my list this year. I think that there are several reasons for that. First, I’m in touch with my feminine side. A real 90s guy, so to speak.
    More importantly, they are just great artists who cranked out some stellar work.

    Here is my top 10 of the year. Get these albums.

    10.5. Mark Knopfler and Emmylou Harris–All The Roadrunning: You get a bonus album because when I was putting this list together I inexplicably forgot about Rhett Miller. You wouldn’t think that this two seemingly disparate voices would blend together so beautifully. But they do. The sacred ethereal quality to Harris’ vocal lifts Knopfler to heights he has never attained. And in the process he makes the beauty of Harris’ voice a little more tangible to us mortals. This album, recorded over seven years, is a travelogue of heartbreak, hope and redemption. Download This: If This Is Goodbye

    10. Brett Dennen–So Much More: If Van Morrison had a guitar-playing, folk-singing child, it would be Dennen. He’s getting lumped in with Jack Johnson, but that’s not fair. This guy can write a song that is much more grounded and real than Johnson. His songs are vivid and powerful with a voice that conveys vulnerability. He looks like he is 12 years old but there is great wisdom in these lyrics. Download This: Ain’t No Reason

    9. Dixie Chicks–Taking The Long Way: Hate them all you want. But these Chicks rock. This album is, at turns, reflective and defiant. Vulnerable and at arms-length. But regardless of how you slice it, their musicianship is unsurpassed. These are songs of family, hope and longing. Download This: The Long Way Around

    8. Rhett Miller–The Believer: The Old 97′s frontman returns with another stellar solo outing on the heels of 2002′s must-have The Instigator. The title song is a tribute to the late, great Elliot Smith. Every song here is brimming with regret and hope. Miller is a master craftsman of catchy tunes. Download This: Help Me, Suzanne

    7. Indigo Girls–Despite Our Differences: After all these years I still don’t know which one is which. And that’s the way I like it. Their voices blend together in anthems of protest, love and social awareness. I didn’t think they could record an album that I would enjoy more than Become You, but I was wrong. This album rocks from start to finish with defiance wrapped around a tender core. If you havent listened to them in a while, it’s high time to check them out again. Download This: Rock and Roll Heaven’s Gate or Pendulum Swinger

    6. Tilly and The Wall–Bottoms of Barrels: It’s hard to classify this Omaha quintet. Take a folk sensibility, 60s psychedelia, soaring harmonies, hand claps and the obligatory tap-dancing member of the band and you have the most eclectic and fun band out there. They describe themselves, aptly, as having “pockets full of melodies and a lot of pockets.” They are products of the Conor Oberst machine. And that’s a good thing. You won’t find an album that will put a bigger smile on your face. Download this: Sing Songs Along and Rainbows in the Dark

    5. Neko Case–Fox Confessor Brings The Flood: You won’t forget this album after you hear it the first time. Her voice is transcendent and she has made an album that is making all of the best of lists. Deservedly so, for this is a sonic masterpiece. You make get lost in her voice, but don’t let that obscure the sheer weight of those lyrics, exploring working class themes and love for those who have fallen through the cracks. Download This, Hold On, Hold On

    4. Jenny Lewis and The Watson Twins–Rabbit Fur Coat: This might be higher if I had listened to it earlier. But, man, this is incredible. Don’t call Lewis a former child actress any longer. The Rilo Kiley singer gets better and better and in this solo debut stakes her territory as a top-notch songwriter. Her voice is enchantingly soulful with a quality of that verges on pure heart-break. This album is rife with songs of spiritual seeking and tremendous stories. Download This: Rabbit Fur Coat.

    3. Kasey Chambers–Carnival: My wife is a little freaked out by how much I love Kasey Chambers. But it’s that voice. I can’t get it out of my head. It’s not the best, but it might be my favorite of all time. There is this childlike vulnerability to her vocal that leaves me speechless. In fact, if you listen, you can often hear the break in her singing. I find it enthralling. This album, though not as great as her debut The Captain, but I still can’t stop playing it. It seems that this Aussie has disappointed her long-time fan base with this more commercial effort. But it still rocks. Download This: The Rain

    2. Mark Erelli–Hope and Other Casualties: Only Springsteen has recorded as indelible a 9/11 reaction album. This song is born out of the destruction and calamity of one of the darkest days our nation has ever experienced. But out of that carnage comes an album brimming with love and hope. Every song resonates with the power to respond, not with vengeance, but with all that is innately good in us. It is the album to listen to when we wish to stop and reflect as to how we should behave. And more importantly, how we are all children of God. Download This: The Only Way

    1. Josh Ritter–The Animal Years: This 29 year old can write. His entry into this years field is unsurpassed in genius, artistry and daring. I defy you to listen to this artist and not be wowed by the greatness of an album that is destined to become one of the most important in rock history. This is his Blonde on Blonde. From the aching “Girl in the War” (video below) to the sonic 9 and a half minute tour-de-force of “Thin Blue Flame” this is, hands down, the album of the year. Download This: Thin Blue Flame

    There you have it. The twenty best albums of the year. I didn’t mess with links but, by all means, scope them out on youtube, myspace and their personal websites. You won’t be sorry.

    One side note: Sandi Thom, the august, Kate Campbell, Hem, Brett Dennen, Neko Case, Mark Erelli and Josh Ritter are all available on emusic. Sign up and get 25 free downloads. Get an invitation from me and I get 50 free downloads. If you are interested, let me know.

    That’s right, I said top 20. That’s because I could not limit the number of albums that I absolutely loved these past 12 months to just 10. There has been some great music churned out recently. There are a million best of lists out there. This, my friends, is the definitive one:

    20. Sandi Thom–Smile, It Confuses People: This one makes it on the virtue of the sugary goodness of “I Wish I Was A Punk Rocker.” Thom was a starving British artist. Too poor to tour, she decided to do a virtual tour from her basement. That led to a recording deal and one of the more upbeat, foot-tap worthy, offerings of the year. Download This: I Wish I Was A Punk Rocker (With Flowers In My Hair)

    19. Neil Young–Living With War: Young churned out this angry, political soaked record on the fly but the passion and intensity keeps the power of this record afloat. It’s no cheery record and will not withstand the test of time. But for now, it’s tremendous protest music. Download This: After The Garden

    18. Jars of Clay–Good Monsters: A thin year for Contemporary Christian Music has a couple of bright spots. One was this veteran group blessing us with another stellar outing. There is nothing new here as they explore the same ground that has served them well for over a decade. Download This: Oh My God

    17. Roseanne Cash–Black Cadillac: All the pain, anger and heartbreak of loss channeled into one poetic tour de force. This is an album that captures the the complexity of grief and managing relationships in a fallen world. This is an album that ranks up there with the best that anyone in her family has ever recorded. And that says a lot. Download This: God Is In The Roses.

    16. Bruce Springsteen–We Shall Overcome: The fact that the Boss sits at number 16 is testament to how much great music has been churned out this year. I’ve long been a fan of folk music and Pete Seeger is one of my favorite voices of protest music. The melding of Rock’s Poet Laureate with Seeger’s tireless words of activism conspired to produce a disc that I’ll still be listening to when I’m Seeger’s age. Make sure you get the re-released version with extra tunes. Download This: Bring ‘Em Home

    15. the august–Thistle, Sparrow and the Tall, Tall Grass: This mesmerizing debut from these Chicago area folk rockerss might be higher on my list but their album came out less than two weeks ago. If this is any indication of the music that they will bless us with then I will be a fan for years to come. Jacky Dustin’s voice is compelling and silky smooth. Download This: Sugar Momma

    14. Yusuf Islam–Another Cup: He will always be Cat Stevens to me. That melancholic voice that I grew up listening to is back with his first pop recording in 28 years. It’s like he never left. If you love vintage Stevens, you will love the sound of his voice cranking out those same profound nuggets of searching for truth, even if you don’t like his destination. Download This: Maybe There’s A World

    13. Kate Campbell–For The Living Of These Days: Campbell is a revelation as she parlays a love for hymns, traditional and contemporary, into a disc of unsurpassed beauty and meaning. Listen to this offering and you will come face to face with a Jesus of incomparable grace and mercy. Download This: God of Grace and God of Glory

    12. Hem–Funnel Cloud: You will not find a more ethereal voice than that of Sally Ellyson. This album is a further indication that they are the heir apparent to all things Timmons and display the sleepy Americana that would make the Cowboy Junkies proud. Fall into that sweet vocal and allow those elaborate strings to wash over you and you will fall in love with these masters of haunting folk-rock. Download This: Not California

    11. Derek Webb–Mockingbird: This is the one Christian album in the last 10 years that made me stop mourning the passing of Rich Mullins. This is a wake-up call for the church to be the in-breaking of the Kingdom. A welcome breath of fresh air in the derivative world of CCM. Download This: A King and a Kingdom

    Tomorrow I will be back with the 10 best albums of 2006. Any thoughts about the first 10? Any guesses about what you will see in the next post?

    Needless to say, I have not abandoned the posts of nonviolence. After the first of the year I plan to move toward an indepth study of the “Way of Christ.” I want to look more closely at what it truly means to follow after Him and what we do with those pesky saying of Jesus. That goes deeper than nonviolence but also to materialism, self-centeredness and humility.
    It will begin with soteriological honesty.

    Are there any thoughts you have about “The Way” or anything you would like to explore in more depth?

    It’s a frantic week for me but I will way in with the best albums of 2006 and some other thoughts. Pray for us that we find child-care. And soon.

    It very well may be. For your Yule Tide pleasure:

    It doesn’t get any better than that.

    Around the Bases

    9 comments

    I was going to post my top 10 Christian books of the year, but losing most of the day to a vicious migraine has made that impossible. I’ll get to that but I still plan on doing my top 10 Albums of the year come Tuesday.

    So, instead, please find a scattering of thoughts.

    I am glad that Mitch Mustain and Ben Cleveland have decided to stay at Arkansas. But two suggestions: get on board and tell your parents to stay off campus.

    Nicolas Cage says that he is going to slow down the movie making. Thank you, Nick.

    –Perusing over the Golden Globe Noms this morning are putting me in the Oscar mood. In case you didn’t know I am a huge Academy Award guy. I have seen every best picture and best actor winner and for the last decade have seen almost all the major nominees. Some thoughts:

    * I’m surprised to see “Bobby” in the Drama category. The only real buzz for this flick was on Oprah and seemed DOA. But it seems to have taken the nom from “Blood Diamond.”
    * Oscar is noted for its backlash. If someone peaks too early they very well could lose (See Brokeback Mountain and Saving Private Ryan). However, I find it hard to believe that Helen Mirren has any competition in the Best Actress race.
    * The biggest existing crime is that Scorsese has never won. You would think that he has a great shot this year with The Departed getting so much buzz. But look, there is Eastwood again. Twice.
    * On the TV side, apart from “The Office,” that is one horrible list of comedy nominees.
    * But look at the nominees for best male comedy actor. That is one stellar lineup with one exception: Jason Lee. I love “My Name is Earl” and I am a Jason Lee fan. But he is nothing more than a straight man who elicits no laughs.

    –And finally, I have updated my podcast page by including my last four sermons. They include:
    “Be Free” from Galatians
    “Be One” from Ephesians
    “Be Like Christ” from Philippians
    “Be Mature” from Colossians (I apologize that this podcast is 8 hours long. It was not shut off after the morning sermon. Fast forward and you can hear my Sunday Night Class.)
    I don’t plan on going so long without updating again.


    Click here to get your own player.

    I only read two books this week and they lie on opposite ends of the spectrum as far as value goes.

    Dissident Discipleship by David Augsburger–I consider those saints who hail from the Anabaptist tradition to be heroes of the faith. Their unswerving commitment to following Christ is a tremendous example for us all. In this instant classic, which I view as a companion piece to Lee Camp’s seminal Mere Discipleship, Augsburger recounts 7 characteristics of their spirituality for us to consider: Radical Attachment, Stubborn Loyalty, Tenacious Serenity, Habitual Humility, Resolute Nonviolence, Concrete Service and Authentic Witness.

    Woven through these seven traits is a “tripolar” spirituality in which “love of God transcends and transforms love of self, love of God and love of neighbor become one, love of neighbor and love of self become one, and submission to God and solidarity with neighbor are indivisible.”

    This book is not one to be missed. Five Stars (OSFSOA)

    The Children of Men by P.D. James–I had high hopes for this book for it had high marks going in: a well reviewed dystopian thriller written by a respected author. The movie will be released in the States on Christmas day and has received some buzz as well. Yet the book was a total disappointment. The premise was intriguing enough: In 1995 the sperm count of all men in the world went to zero. It is now 2021 and the youngest living people are 25 years old. The world has changed greatly as those living anticipate the death of mankind.
    But James fails to do anything great with this premise. The story-line drags and too much is invested in scene setting and not enough on providing any level of impetus to keep turning the page. I began to skim the last 30 pages just to get to the, underwhelming, conclusion.
    As far as the movie version, I hear they abandoned most of the storyline of the book and just used it as a skeleton. That’s promising. Two Stars.

    My Top 10 Fiction Reads of the Year

    10. The Life of Pi by Yann Martel
    9. The Chosen by Chaim Potok
    8. The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood
    7. Cell by Stephen King
    6. The Innocent by Harlan Coben
    5. Things Fall Apart by Chinua Achebe
    4. All Quiet On the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque
    3. The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini
    2. Oryx and Crake by Margaret Atwood
    1. The Time Traveler’s Wife by Audrey Niffenegger

    I read voraciously. I figure that I have read somewhere in the neighborhood of 150+ books this past year. Over three entries I will attempt to give you my top picks for the year.
    This entry will comprise nonfiction releases. In subsequent postings I will tackle my favorite fiction and Christian themed writings.

    With a couple of notable exceptions these titles were written this year.

    10. Rednecks and Bluenecks: The Politics of Country Music by Chris Willman–Despite the overwhelming appearance, there is broad range of political beliefs in the Nashville country music scene. Although overwhelmingly conservative, there is still a faction of progressive country artists. Willman does a thorough job of describing the entire spectrum from Toby Keith to The Dixie Chicks.

    9. The Wal-Mart Effect: How the World’s Most Powerful Company Really Works–and How It’s Transforming the American Economy by Charles Fishman–This is the most balanced assessment of the impact of the world’s biggest store that I have come across. If it an informative, critical look at the behemoth.

    8. Fantasyland by Sam Walker–No matter what, I can rest assured that I don’t take fantasy sports anywhere near as seriously as the guys in this behind the scenes look at the most elite fantasy baseball league in the world.

    7. Nonviolence: 25 Lessons From the History of a Dangerous Idea by Mark Kurlansky–Kurlansky takes the historical approach to nonviolence and weaves a powerful argument for the use of nonviolent means. The authors conclusions and arguments are uneven and somewhat polemical, but it is still a useful resource in my reading.

    6. American Gospel: God, the Founding Fathers and the Making of a Nation by Jon Meacham–This is a well-researched look at the history of our nation and our continual commitment to religious tolerance. Our founding fathers were religious, yes. But the argument he makes is the commitment to allow people of all beliefs and backgrounds to have equal access to their faith and protection to worship. A great argument for the continued success of the separation of church and state.

    5. An Ordinary Man: An Autobiography by Paul Rusesabagina–The author, inspiration for the stirring film Hotel Rwanda, tells his story of nonviolent resistance to the Rwandan massacres amidst the backdrop of the historical and cultural missteps that led to such a dark chapter in the history of man.

    4. Tulia: Race, Cocaine, and Corruption in a Small Texas Town by Nate Blakeslee–The criminal justice system in America is deeply flawed. No greater testament to that exists than this harrowing depiction of a small town in Texas and the corrupt lawmakers who run roughshod over lower income blacks. That prominent members of the local Church of Christ figure into such abuses of justice is most unfortunate. This is a gripping read that will leave you shocked that this sort of thing can continue to happen in America.

    3. Sundown Towns: A Hidden Dimension of American Racism by James Loewen–The author’s thesis is that in post-Civil War America and leading up to the year of my birth there was the establishment of thousands of Sundown Towns across America, towns that did not permit blacks to reside or even linger after sundown. Loewen takes this preposterous notion and backs it up with copious research and exhaustive detail. This book should be an essential part of our civil rights education.

    2. The Great Deluge: Hurricane Katrina, New Orleans, and the Mississippi Gulf Coast by Douglas Brinkley–The lack of preparedness, the slow response and the overall negligent mismanagement of all things Katrina will go down as one of, if not the greatest, failure our nation has ever known. Brinkley gives a detailed, harrowing account of that week. This book is not to be missed.

    1. Parting The Waters, Pillar of Fire, and At Canaan’s Edge: America in the King Years, 1954-68 by Taylor Branch–As you can probably guess, I spent much of this year reading about civil rights and race relations. The intent was to further explore the deep recesses of my own heart and deal, ever so painfully, with my own prejudices and hatreds. Nothing was more informative and telling than Branch’s masterful trilogy that recaptures those tumultuous years of the Dr. King era. These books are voluminous and engrossing. I read each of them and emerged changed. I realized more of the legacy of hatred that runs rampant in our society. This work is one of the most important things I have ever read. Do yourself a favor and read this opus.

    Any thoughts on these works? What were your favorite nonfiction reads of the year?

    I am thinking about putting the nonviolence series to rest for a while. I’m not sure I want to abandon it completely. And I know that there are still issues to discuss and, yes, suss out.
    But in moving toward a discussion of the nonviolence advocate and his relationship with the nation state (i.e. America) I’m not sure that a civil and productive discussion could be maintained.
    On the way to church yesterday, I saw a guy riding a motorcycle, pulling a cross decorated to look like the United States flag. There are many reasons I find that offensive, but I’m not sure that these issues can be discussed in a positive manner in today’s climate.

    With that said, I have a few thoughts.

    1. Do we merely believe in Jesus or do we believe what Jesus believed? This question, posed by Clarence Baumer, has shaken me this past week. I’m good at professing a faith in Christ. But have I moved enough in my discipleship where I hold the same beliefs that Jesus did: that the meek will inherit the earth, that loving your enemies is the right way to treat them, that turning the other cheek is more effective than retaliation? I think if we are honest then we will find that there are truths that Jesus held dear that we don’t necessarily share. It’s a sobering thought, but Jesus didn’t operate according to logic, reason or earthly practicality. For us to adopt that belief system means more than merely imitation. It necessitates transformation.

    2. “Just War” advocates and nonviolence proponents are not that far apart. Therefore we must work together to find ways to alleviate the amount of violence in this fallen world. David Augsburger, in his tremendous Anabaptist primer and Mere Discipleship companion piece, writes:

    Those who teach just war ethics are not on the opposing side from those who teach nonviolence because both seek to limit the use of violence–the just war believers through a limited participation in war; the nonviolence disciples through constructive practices of peacemaking that, if followed, point toward the elimination of war. As friends we press one another to be more faithful to our goals, more consistent in our practices.

    Although, I completely reject the notion of just war and militarism, that does not mean that I am unable to work with those who disagree with me toward the cessation of violence. I do not believe that the use of violence can be reconciled with the teachings of Jesus. I do not believe it is the way of Christ. However, I am in full fellowship with wonderful brothers and sisters who disagree sharply with me. Yet we are still children of God, saved by grace and grace alone. May we work together.

    3. We must continually make sure that we do not conflate the missions of the Kingdom and America. The “America as Christian Nation” notion does not baptize all that we do regardless of the consequences. Clay Jenkinson, Theodore Roosevelt scholar-in-residence at Dickinson State University recently had a tremendous article in the Bismarck Tribune. Here is an excerpt:

    Most Americans, then and now, do not share Jefferson’s and Paine’s distaste for the Bible or their antagonism to institutional religion. A solid majority of the Founding Fathers were Christians in some sense of the term. Some of them, like Patrick Henry, wanted an official established religion in each state. Most believed that religion was an important restraining mechanism in human affairs. Many of them, if we could lift them out of their context and into ours, would probably be distressed by the degree to which we have chosen to prohibit religious activity in the public square.

    It is easy for religious conservatives to compile anthologies of pro-Christian sentiment from the founders’ writings, including – with a bit of disingenuous manipulation – from the works of Jefferson. There is room for an honest debate about what the founders intended, but any honest participant acknowledges that there is plenty of “evidence” on both sides of the argument. In other words, there is no definitive “intent of the Founding Fathers” on religious questions.

    It is certain that the United States is a more religious country in 2006 than it was in 1806. For Jefferson, who declared in 1822 that “there is not a young man now living in the U.S. who will not die an Unitarian,” this would come as a surprise and something of a disappointment. Jefferson, like Paine, believed that science and reason would emancipate mankind from faith systems, and that at some future, but near, date, all people would admire, though not worship, the one universal deity.

    If there were an unambiguous intent of the founders, there would be no special reason for us to follow their lead 219 years later. Their intent was to perpetuate slavery. Their intent was to count every five slaves as three for the purposes of apportionment and representation. Their intent was that senators would be elected by state legislatures. Their intent was that the Electoral College would sit in independent judgment about who was fittest to be president. Their intent was to exclude all women, almost all African-Americans, all Indians and white males without property from voting or holding public office.

    We have discarded all these 18th century notions because they do not serve us well in the 21st century. Nor, in a nation with as much religious diversity as the United States, does it make any sense to force the 5.8 million Muslims, the 5.2 million Jews, the 1.5 million Buddhists, the 1 million Hindus, and the 433,267 Wiccans, pagans and Druids under one Christian tent. About this the First Amendment is very clear.

    The government of the United States is overwhelmingly tolerant of the widest possible variety of religions and religious sensibilities. Nobody is legally punished for being a Mormon, a Christian Scientist, a British Israelist, a Mennonite, a Deuteronomist, a Scientologist or a member of a Native American peyote tradition. Members of each of these groups have held public office in the United States. We have no test oaths that prevent Catholics or Anabaptists from holding public office. A Catholic has been president. A Mormon (Gov. Mitt Romney of Massachusetts) plans to run for the presidency. Joe Lieberman, who is Jewish, nearly became vice president of the United States in 2000.

    In this our happy and tolerant republic, tax exemption is afforded to individuals and groups whose religious views would be unrecognizable to the Founding Fathers, and deeply abhorrent.

    The “wall of separation” between church and state works. We have the freethinking Founding Fathers, among them Tom Paine, to thank for that great gift to human freedom and diversity.

    Any thoughts?